Skip to main content
Home

Main navigation

News & Analysis Policies & Forms Your Library Attorney Network
News & Analysis Policies & Forms Your Library Attorney Network

User account menu

Sign in Get Started
x

You're signed out

Sign in to access subscriber actions.

Gene mutation can be a disability under ADA

August 2020 employment law letter
Authors: 
Franck G. Wobst, Porter Wright Morris & Arthur LLP

In the first time any federal appeals court had heard a case on the issue, the U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals (whose rulings apply to all Michigan and Ohio employers) recently overruled a district court and held that a noncancerous gene mutation can be a disability covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).

Facts

Sherryl Darby was employed as an administrative assistant by Childvine, Inc., an early childcare provider, from August 2016 to November 2016. She underwent a double mastectomy on October 25 and received written notice of her termination approximately two weeks after her surgery. Childvine's stated reasons for termination were "an unpleasant" attitude, dress code violations, and "being unable to work."

On September 21, 2018, Darby filed suit against Childvine in the federal district court in Cincinnati. Her complaint alleged disability discrimination claims under the ADA and Ohio's nondiscrimination statute. During discovery (pretrial exchange of evidence), Childvine learned Darby was not diagnosed with cancer as alleged in her amended complaint, but instead had tested positive for a gene mutation—BRCA1—that is associated with an increased risk of cancer.

Childvine filed a request to dismiss Darby's claims. It argued that because she had never actually been diagnosed with cancer, she wasn't "disabled" within the meaning of the ADA or Ohio law.

Continue reading your article with a HRLaws membership
  • Sign in
  • Sign up
Upgrade to a subscription now
to get unlimited access to everything on HR Laws.
Start subscription
Any time

Publications

  • Employment Law Letter
  • Employers State Law Alert
  • Federal Employment Law Insider

Your Library Reading List

Reading list 6
Creating List 7
Testing

Let's manage your states

We'll keep you updated on state changes

Manage States
© 2025
BLR®, A DIVISION OF SIMPLIFY COMPLIANCE LLC | ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Footer - Copyright

  • terms
  • legal
  • privacy